Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.
Comment: Wrote up the test so far. More testing next week

Introduction

Ever since computers were invented, the ability to communicate with them was paramount. The RS 232 serial port became the standard way to do this. Modern computers now use USB ports to communicate together be it a camera, mobile phone or a hard disk drive.

There are programs on the internet that test Serial Ports. The object of this section is to use these programs to test the different USB Serial cables that are candidates to use with Eazylink2.

Method

Image Modified
Software

The following windows software was downloaded. 

File NameRelease DateVersionFile Size
PL2303_CableTest_v2.2.1.1.zip2010/02/252.2.1.1753.78KB
COM PORT STRESS TESTMarch 11, 2014.1.4.3 build 907.  

Hardware

The following items were made

NameItemCircuit
Loopback
Connector
NULL MODEM
adapter

Tested USB Serial Cables

4 cables are tested. These are:-


PL2303HX
PLUGABLE


FT232R
TRONIX 

FT232R
CHIP-10X 


TUSB3410

Test & Results

Run as administrator

It was found that unless these programs were "Run as administrator," errors and a Blue Screen Of Death were encountered.

PL-2303 - Cable Test Program Ver 2.2.1.1

This program tests two serial ports connected together by a NULL MODEM cable, by sending data from one port to the other, changing parameter settings and reporting the results.

Image Added

This screen shot shows a successful test provided that the Check Signal Events was un-ticked.

The RTS Signal testing ... section failed. This was due to the NULL MODEM cable was a 3 wire type. This only connects the data pins together. At least it shows that this program reports errors correctly.

 

This test will be run again with a fully connected NULL MODEM adapter.

 

 

 

Image Removed

 

 

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

 

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removed

http://www.home-machine-shop.com/bits/NULL_MODEM_CABLE.jpg

Com Port Stress Test

This program tests serial individually, using the Loopback connector or with 2 COM ports as above.

If the COM port is faulty, error messages are generated and recorded into a log file. The following screen shot shows COM3 and COM4 connected together with the 3 wire NULL MODEM with RTS CTS selected randomly. As expected, error messages, like the result above were generated.

Image Added

These tests will be repeated when I have the correct NULL MODEM Adapter.

Single USB Serial Cable Results

USB Serial Port (COM3) FTDI Results

Image Added

Image Added

This test shows this test running at 38400 baud with RTS and CTS enabled. There are different values in the port settings. This has no effect on the speed of transfer. There are no errors.

Keyspan USB Serial Port (COM5) Results

Image Added

Image Added

This test shows this test running at 38400 baud with RTS and CTS enabled. There are different values in the port settings. This has no effect on the speed of transfer. There are no errors.

USB Serial Port (COM6) FTDI Results

Image Added

Image Added

This test shows this test running at 38400 baud with RTS and CTS enabled. There are different values in the port settings. This has no effect on the speed of transfer. There are no errors.

Prolific USB-to-Serial Comms Port (COM4) Results

will be displayed here

Conclusion

Initial tests look promising. Both FTDI cables and the Keyspan pass the individual test.

The Prolific one didn't pass the test when connected to another USB Serial Cable, but this could be due to the incorrect NULL MODEM being used.